Historical Dilemmas: What Would You Do?

About this tool

Each card tells a real decision from the past in the second person, without saying who or when: you command an army, you are asked to sign a treaty, you must give up a bus seat. The class discusses what they would do and why, then flips the card to find out who it was, what was actually decided and what followed. The 16 cards cover different eras and continents, from ancient Rome and Ethiopia to the Cold War and the civil rights movement. They are written to be factual and sober. Edit the cards or add decisions from your own unit.

Classroom ideas

  • Show the front, give pairs two minutes to decide, take a show of hands, then flip the card to compare.
  • Ask students to list what the person knew at the time, and what they could not have known.
  • Have students write a new card for a decision from the period you are studying and swap them.

Related tools